Tiffany’s Custom Cakes in Rotterdam, NY, is the kind of bakery and cake shop that turns everyday moments into memorable celebrations. Known for its custom cakes and welcoming service, this local favorite has earned a strong reputation among customers, with a 4.70 out of 5 rating based on 54 reviews.
Whether you’re planning a birthday, wedding, anniversary, shower, or another special occasion, Tiffany’s Custom Cakes brings the care, creativity, and attention to detail that help make each order feel personal and meaningful.
A great bakery does more than bake—it helps create the centerpiece for life’s most important gatherings, offering both beauty and flavor in every custom creation.
Customers appreciate the convenience and flexibility offered here, with kerbside pickup, delivery, and dine-in available to fit different needs and schedules. The shop is thoughtfully accessible, featuring a wheelchair-accessible car park, wheelchair-accessible seating, and a wheelchair-accessible toilet, helping ensure a comfortable experience for more visitors.
Additional amenities such as a restroom add to the convenience, while appointment-required planning allows the team to focus on creating carefully prepared cakes and a more personalized customer experience. Payment is simple and straightforward with cash and cheques accepted.
Located at 124 Rotterdam St, Rotterdam, NY 12306, Tiffany’s Custom Cakes is easy to find and ready to serve customers looking for quality, convenience, and a bakery they can trust.
For anyone searching for a dependable cake shop that combines craftsmanship with a warm, customer-focused approach, Tiffany’s Custom Cakes stands out as a place where special orders are handled with care.
From the first conversation to the final presentation, the experience is designed to bring peace of mind and a finished product that feels worth celebrating. Call +1 518-860-9439 to plan your order and discover why so many customers return for cakes that are as memorable as the occasions they honor.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Tiffany's Custom Cakes
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Hear from our valued guests
Ordering through Tiffany’s website was easy and she contacted me quickly to get details about what I was looking for. She was flexible with pick up time and very responsive via text. Everyone loved the cake pops she made, and the bonus/thank you cookie she gave as a sample was delicious. I would absolutely order from her again!
We have ordered many cakes from Tiffany, she never disappoints with her creativity and craft. Her cakes are always moist and tasty and her design skills are outstanding. This is her most recent work, it was for my son’s birthday.10 out of 10 I would recommend her.
The birthday cake came out perfectly, better than the inspo picture I provided. It was easy to order and on time, love the ease of communication. But, most importantly the cake was beautiful and delicious. I'm so happy to have found a reliable and talented baker near me! Definitely will be a return customer.
I’ve ordered two cakes from Tiffany and both cakes were breath taking! When she brought my baby shower cake to life I was very impressed.My most recent cake the guest loved. From the flawless details to the delicious taste. 5 stars are truly not enough ! Thank you so much for the service you provide.
Tiffany made my baby shower cake along with cookies, Cakepops and cupcakes. The presentation of each was very impressive and beautiful! The feedback was outstanding on the taste and moistness of all of them. She truly knows what she’s doing and has fair pricing. Will definitely be reaching out to her again in the future! Thanks Tiffany!
Tiffany made a cake for a combined company birthday celebration. It far exceeded my expectations. It was delicious and her design was amazing. I highly recommend her and will definitely be using her again! From placing the order to picking it up everything was perfect!
I’ve been buying cakes from Tiffany for years now, and she never fails to absolutely blow me away. Her designs are insanely detailed like, truly next-level talent. Every cake looks so perfect it almost feels wrong to cut into it… and then somehow it tastes even better than it looks! Moist, flavorful, and always exactly what I asked for. Tiffany is hands-down my go-to for any occasion. If you need a cake that’s both stunning and delicious, she’s the one.
Tiffany does such a beautiful job on her cakes and cupcakes! Not only do they look amazing but they are so delicious! Tiffany has made multiple cakes and cupcakes for our special events and everyone at my parties always talks about how amazing they are!
I’ve used Tiffany twice now. Once for my daughter’s gender reveal and then for her baby shower. She does beautiful work and not only are her cupcakes and cakes beautiful but they are delicious!! She is very talented and will design what you are looking for by just looking at a picture. I would definitely recommend Tiffany for any occasion. All my guests commented and loved the desserts!
I was looking for a custom cake and found Tiffany on Google. So glad I did. Her cakes are amazing both in looks and taste. Everyone at all my parties raved about how good the cakes and cupcakes were. Everything from placing my order, during and pick up was very pleasant and professional. I will be ordering again!
Common questions about Tiffany's Custom Cakes
Tiffany's Custom Cakes is located at 124 Rotterdam St, Rotterdam, NY 12306, United States, Rotterdam, NY, United States.
You can reach Tiffany's Custom Cakes by calling +1 518-860-9439.
Tiffany's Custom Cakes has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 based on 54 customer reviews.
Tiffany's Custom Cakes features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible seating, Wheelchair-accessible toilet.
Tiffany's Custom Cakes features the following from the business: Identifies as women-owned.
Tiffany's Custom Cakes features the following service options: Kerbside pickup, Delivery, Dine-in.
Tiffany's Custom Cakes features the following amenities: Restroom.
Tiffany's Custom Cakes features the following crowd: LGBTQ+ friendly, Transgender safe space.
Tiffany's Custom Cakes features the following planning: Appointment required.
Tiffany's Custom Cakes features the following payments: Cash only, Cheques.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
